TIE-TC 199: Shinsen Gumi Saga #1: The School For Scandal

Battle Information

Game platform: TIE Fighter
Missions: 4
Release date: 2002-06-18
Last updated: 2003-09-09
Average rating: 3.6
Reviews: 8
Bug reports: 1
Times completed: 168
Patches used: None

Battle Reviews

LC Aardvark

2

2022-04-13

The attempts at humor in the briefings go over my head at detract from the any feeling of immersion in the missions. In the readme it reveals that this battle is part of the author's character back-story, which is a nice touch. However, this battle is plagued by poor design elements and lack of polish. The difficulty modes are not balanced and there are some goals which are essentially unattainable given the time constraints. It's a pity, because I think this battle has real potential, just not in its current form.


GN Mark Schueler

1

2022-04-13

As is often the case, when a battle is praised for being 'funny', it's a sign that the battle is otherwise poorly made. This is very much the case here, with unclear goals, elements of design that just suck - such as the Daedalus not firing at its attackers in M1, and poor choice of warheads. There is one mission, for example, where you need to attack a capital ship, but you're assigned advanced missiles by default.


LC randyrumrnr

5

2022-04-12

This battle was quite a bit of fun to fly. While the majority of it revolves around dogfighting, there are a few other objectives and ways to go about completing the battles. I thought the storyline was pretty good and well written. I didn't encounter any bugs.


COL Rau Aznable

5

2005-02-18

This battle has it all! Humour, action, a real challenge, you name it! I really loved it and I can't wait to try the sequel.


LT Edward De'Galeon

4

2002-07-11

This is a fun battle with some interesting missions and funny briefings, provided that you can make it past the first mission without destroying your joystick. I played that mission for several hours last night and 30 minutes this morning and finally beat it. I then raced through the rest of the missions with little difficulty. That’s kind of a poor way to organize the difficulty in a battle. Difficulty should increase as the battle goes along, not decrease. The hardest mission should be at the end so that pilots who have worked really hard to reach the end will want to finish, if for no other reason that to see their work finished. Having the first mission being so difficult will just turn folks away. Still, I recommend it, but I warn the player to be aware of that first step so to speak. I give it a 4.30 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


COL Carl Lost

4

2002-07-05

Cool plotline and reasonably well gameplay :) I like it !


CM Gandalf

4

2002-06-23

Interesting battle that requires me to exercise my tactical muscles. :) Funny debriefing after the last mission, heh heh.


COL D. T. Hammer

4

2002-06-23

Pretty good mission with a nice difficulty level.


Battle Bug Reports

LC Aardvark

2022-04-11

M2: Enemy corvettes 2 and 3 collide.


High Scores

Battle Total: 195,705 AD Ranthier Khaen
Mission 1: 42,715 COL Genie 2022-05-08
Mission 2: 80,644 COL Genie 2022-05-08
Mission 3: 39,993 COL Genie 2022-05-13
Mission 4: 49,593 AD Ranthier Khaen

Top Ten

(Submissions since 2010)

1 188,784 COL Genie 2022-05-08
2 182,348 COL Genie 2022-05-08
3 174,377 COL Phalk Sturm 2022-05-07
4 154,030 LC Aardvark 2022-05-06
5 153,902 COL NiksaVel 2022-04-18
6 144,808 CPT Colo Delste 2022-04-20
7 131,259 COL Genie 2022-05-13
8 128,185 CPT Wildfire 2022-05-07
9 125,442 LC Aardvark 2022-04-11
10 95,178 CPT Jaxx Nassin 2022-05-08

Battle Completion Statistics

This battle has been flown by 148 pilots a total of 168 times.