Reviewer Rating Profile

Lieutenant Colonel Frey Gallandro (#7430)

Reviewer Average Rating: 4.1
Number of Battle Reviews: 22
5
Reviewed: 2004-01-01
Reviewed: 2004-01-01
eewwww, a very cool Battle by Frodo, the Hell is freezing over ;) Nah, very good work Frodo, I really enjoyed the Battle and the Storyline.
4
Reviewed: 2004-01-01
Nice :)
4
Reviewed: 2003-02-23
cool Battle :) those MTRNS nearly killed me, bad things :)
4
Reviewed: 2003-02-17
Reviewed: 2003-02-17
Frodo starts making good Battles ;) Honestly, very well designed, but sick plotline, but well designed :)
3
Reviewed: 2003-02-07
Reviewed: 2003-02-07
It is my first Battle i ever made, so it is a bit, well, simple. I learned a few things since then :) At least, have fun :)
4
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
One huge Dogfight :) But enjoyable :)
5
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
THAT was really a good one !
4
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
Reviewed: 2003-01-27
hehe, cool Battle, just a bit difficult for me :)
5
Reviewed: 2003-01-26
Reviewed: 2003-01-26
Excellent Battle, finally the vong are entering the EH universe :) Battle is free of bugs, enjoy it !
5
Reviewed: 2002-12-22
Reviewed: 2002-12-22
wow, THIS Battle rocks !!!
4
Reviewed: 2002-12-22
would have been a 5 if the last mission would have a bit more, uhm, action :) Cool Battle Frodo :)
4
Reviewed: 2002-12-08
cool mission :)
5
Reviewed: 2002-11-30
Reviewed: 2002-11-30
nice idea, excellent work !!! I really enjoyed it :)
4
Reviewed: 2002-07-05
Reviewed: 2002-07-05
I really enjoyed the dogfights in this Battle and it was nice to see some well known faces again :)
4
Reviewed: 2002-05-30
Reviewed: 2002-05-30
was fun :)
0
Reviewed: 2002-05-25
Reviewed: 2002-05-25
it is the worst battle i`ve ever played ! The storyline is idealess, Mission 2,3 and 5 are crap. Sorry Frodo, but for someone who rated his own Battle with a 4 and who is presenting such a Battle is 0 the only rating i can give. The tester who flew it should die painfully ! You asked for constructive critic, ok, i will try my best. The first mission is from the "action" part ok, but the idea to fire at my own comrades and to kill them just to become the Acting Wingcommander scares me deply. If i fire at my own comrades, something basically went wrong. Mision 2, if i remember right it is the mission where you need to fight against several X-Wings and Escort Shuttles with a single T/F. The only good thing i can find in the mission is that you have shields when you attack 1 Escort Shuttle and loop back from it just to fly in the fire of the other 15 shuttles, i don`t think that i would ever be confrontaded with such a situation, especially when an ISD is hanging in the space, just 3 klicks away. And the mission where you fight with a single Assault Gunboat against the 5 manufacturing platforms, i mean, ok, you just need to destroy 3 of it and you have enough rockets to kill 1 of them with the help of some laser shoots, but to destroy the other two within 4 mins is really difficult for a normal skilled pilot. I don`t fell blamed when i say that i completed the T/F Mission with unlimited waves because i got destroyed to often. Also the Gunboat Mission, because i lost the fun when i flew the battle. Battles are made to have fun by flying, a Battle who kills the fun by flying it isn`t what i would rate as a good Battle, and all in all, i think it is really shameless to rate his own battle with a 4, if you think it is good let others fly it and let them rate it, but don`t do it on yourself. I won`t remove my rating, just you feeled pissed by me, if you can`t life with the critic, take a look atthe others who rated it. It is still the worst battle i ever flew.
5
Reviewed: 2002-05-15
Excellent Battle, you can fly it in HARD with average skills.
5
Reviewed: 2002-02-16
Reviewed: 2002-02-16
Hell, this was a great Battle !!!!
4
Reviewed: 2002-02-14
Reviewed: 2002-02-14
Very difficult in some Missions, the last one is to easy, but all in all, good work ! The only thing that disturbs me is that you can`t choose the weapons you load.
3
Reviewed: 2002-02-14
Reviewed: 2002-02-14
You can fly all Battles in HARD, equal what kind of Pilot you are. Angel, if you would made all Missions like the last one, i would kiss you and give you a Rating of 5 ! The X-Wing and A-Wing Pilots are flying like CT`s in their first hours. Give them a better AI !
5
Reviewed: 2001-12-04
Reviewed: 2001-12-04
COOL !!! Continue !!!
4
Reviewed: 2001-09-29
Reviewed: 2001-09-29
Cool Battle !

Showing all 22 records