Reviewer Rating Profile
Rear Admiral Genie (#55730)
Reviewer Average Rating: 3.2Number of Battle Reviews: 590
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
One of those battles with some flaws that place it somewhere between a 4 and a 5. But knowing the work, time and dedication it takes to put a good, polished battle out there I am upping this one to a 5. Solid storyline with some interesting concepts that could have been explored a bit more.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
There are moments of brilliance in this one. I recommend giving it a go. We are probably going to see it in a TCIB competition soon. :D As with most battles it's not perfect but it does enough to deserve a 5.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
Reviewed: 2021-10-31
This was a well-thought out and well-crafted battle. Some of the smaller things it got so right. I was never left wondering whether I missed something or whether my waiting is all in vein and more. For this it gets a 5.
2
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Unpolished, with several minor bugs / issues and the occasional friendly ramming into capita ships at the very start of a mission. The missions themselves are not that great and the last mission was redundant and felt out of place as it was essentially a duplicate of mission 5.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
I liked this one very much. It looks and feels polished. It was a joy to play it, I highly recommend giving it a try. Might return and try it on hard!
2
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Mission 2 is not calibrated well. I wonder if its mission creator actually completed it. Will note it for revisit at a future date.
3
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
There are some gems hidden in this battle, and yet some parts feel not so grat. It's always a joy to get behind the wheel of an X-Wing or a B-Wing etc. In mission 3, go and attack the two Calamaris in the far distance :D
3
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
I love flying in X-Wings, B-Wings, even Y-Wings on the XvT engine. So I always start off with the right foot when it comes to IW battles. I feel this battle hasnt been tested thoroughly by its creator. For example, objectives get automatically triggered on the start of some missions. The obligatory 'let your pilot know he needs to wait' flight message is missing and sometimes it makes you wonder whether you screwed up or missed out on some instruction. The last mission was though very appropriate!
3
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
I love flying in X-Wings, B-Wings, even Y-Wings on the XvT engine. So I always start off with the right foot when it comes to IW battles. I feel this battle hasnt been tested thoroughly by its creator. For example, objectives get automatically triggered on the start of some missions. The obligatory 'let your pilot know he needs to wait' flight message is missing and sometimes it makes you wonder whether you screwed up or missed out on some instruction. The last mission was though very appropriate!
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
There are no flaws per se, but it also doesnt offer anything spectacular. The parrot jokes, I get that some may find them funny. That one didnt connect with me but I am not holding it against him either. Give it a whirl.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Missions 1 and 4 are precious gems and a reminder of Frodo's ingenuity and creativity. I like this battle overall. I flew this with the dockyard fix so there were no SSD issues here (be sure to take the patches on display).
3
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Had some nice ingredients in it, but lacked of any real umph. Play it for completion points, otherwise, there is not that much to tell.
2
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
I agree with Dempsey and Phalk. It's a shame this had all the ingredients to be quite a good one and it felt nice to fly the Advanced Missile Boat (a Lambda fighter ;) ). It's an ok battle.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
One of Ender's better battles. Well-crafted, the briefing is good the missions are also leading to a very appropriate and fitting climax. The ship selection at the end was also... appropriate. No spoilers, give it a spin.
3
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
It's ok as a battle. I will try it on hard before putting in a final score, but on lower difficulties it is a bit underwhelming.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
The briefing is well-made with a solid storyline of working your way towards capturing a frigate for intel information. It's a solid battle, one of Ender's hits. I recommend giving it a go.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
A solid campaign showcasing the strengths of the TIE Assault. It is surprisingly quite well made. No complaints here. It's not doing anything revolutionary but it's a joy to fly it.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
Reviewed: 2021-10-30
I love this battle. Storyline, briefing etc everything is great and the last mission is also a great one. The problems are in the details, which keeps it at a 4 our of 5 and I do agree the first missions are a bit repetitive. Could have had some variation there.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Fun and entertaining. A bit better than most of its counterparts taking into account that players may try things outside the regular run of things. So bonus point for that.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
I like this one and even though it's a bit stretching to give it a 5, given the amount of garbage I recently flew, this one is a diamond in the rough. So bumping it to a 5/5. Nice use of the craft and challenging in a good way.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Phalk and Mark, I urge you to give this one another go. It is a masterpiece. Ok, not a masterpiece but it's cleverly done. A welcome change from most of the missions on this compendium.
4
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Reviewed: 2021-10-29
Almost everything about this mission is good. There is a question mark on why the rebels are harassing an Imperial Yard that is expected to be heavily defended but otherwise an excellent mission. Also, some interesting events are unfolding during the entire defense so be sure to keep your eyes peeled.
2
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
I was wondering when someone would make a mission to blow up an SSD. It took a while to run into one. Having said that, what could have been a great experience is actually a snoozefest even with all the rockets you have at your disposal. I lasted through the whole thing just to watch it explode.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
I liked this one a lot. It has a very good setup. Does it deserve a 5, not sure but a single mission is it quite good. I will refly it on hard at some point.
5
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
Reviewed: 2021-10-28
I loved this one. I like the fact a neutral 3rd party got embroiled in the Imperial vs Rebel affairs as it often would. I like the fact that there are several moving parts within the mission itself, forcing you to think where to go next. I recommend flying it.