This should not have such a high rating. A combination of mission mechanics and an inconsistent skill requirements make for a wonky experience.
- Mission 1 must be done in a specific order or mission critical craft travel too close to enemy ships and are destroyed, failing the mission.
- Mission 2 has no 'easy' setting, meaning on the easiest mode(shy of unlimited waves) a lower skilled pilot will get wasted quickly. There is also no time limit for disabling the shuttle. The stated goals show the shuttle I'm [supposedly]expected to disable is suppose to complete its mission, making it not intuitive that I should be disabling the ship. Having the capture craft slowly crawling across 22km of space(due to a late disable) is also very unfortunate.
- Mission 6 has 0 time limit to capturing the transport. The patrolling craft also just fly around until you attack the transport. No joke, I completed this 1 mission in 4hrs 20min. I guess I'm happy that it is so forgiving, but it shouldn't be THAT forgiving.
- Mission 8? You're in a defender and there's no craft to kill. Sure there's plenty of things to shoot at, but the AI has that completely covered. Every enemy dies within seconds.
- Mission 9 has you flying a Phantom? That would be 'ok' if the cockpit looked right, but it doesn't. You're staring at cross members of the front window the whole time(no, it's not suppose to be like that even with 2 pilots... and outward display is reversed, as the main pilot sits on the right, not the left) It's also not clear what dictates how you stay "undetected" in stealth mode or how you lose 500 points for breaking "stealth," a mechanic that I don't think is actually in the game?
I'm grateful for the battle to fly... but this really needs some work.

An excellent battle with a little bit of everything and a ton of dogfighting, including some unexpected surprises along the way. Well put together, only complaint is some missions have 100+ fighters which gets to be a bit much but quite enjoyable nonetheless.

A lovely battle ! Missions are enjoyably short and varied, with a solid plot line carrying the whole. Having so much craft variety available during mission planning is a treat.

My hundred and thirteenth battle in the TIE Corps.

Really well put together mission set with good progression in the story side of things. There is a lot of dogfighting and having to inspect craft. Lots of variety craft in this one too and some of the missions are pretty long. Altogether I enjoyed this one.

A pleasant battle with an intriguing storyline. Some missions are rather short and complete almost by themselves, and though it's always fun to fly a TIE Phantom, there are better craft available for that specific mission. Overall, a solid four out of five.

This battle is a monumental project. It has a powerful plotline and is nicely written. The briefings and all preliminaries are performed flawlessly as well. Now, the missions are however a bit unbalanced. The wonderful thing is you get to fly the TIE Praetor and a variety of different crafts and roles, even as a bounty hunter in R-41 or unshielded T/Fs. The campaign feels long and strenuous to finish, so player will be required to endure long waiting times and challenging enemies here and there. Last mission, however drags the high level of quality otherwise obtained until then. Flying a shieldless T/F against multiple fighters can be achievable, but engaging capital ships or installations is total madness. Be mindful of what you do in that last mission or it can become frustrating in the end.

This was a complex and long battle. I couldn't quite follow the plot, but I'm playing it for the FCHG points, so I might not be the best judge. There's something going on with clones and a cloaking device, but the plot wasn't essential for completing the missions.