Reviewing the Line

Competition ID #: 3006
Status: Finished
Submitted by: HA Plif
Competition dates: 2018-08-05 - 2018-09-05
Subgroup: TIE Corps
Units involved: Entire TC
Description: XvT-TC battle 146: Securing the Line was just released. During its first month, fly the battle and then submit a review for it. The best review will earn its author an IS-GR, second best an IS-SR, and third best an IS-BR. Judging will be conducted by at least two officers of the Admiralty Board plus the TAC, which gives us some flexibility in case one of them is a participant.

What makes a good review?

The best reviews are ones that objectively look at the merits of a battle alongside its foibles, then draw a conclusion based on the points it presented earlier. There's definitely some subjectivity involved in looking at something that happened in the battle as positive or negative, but a good review will make it clear how the author reached those conclusions.

How to participate: AD Plif will capture the posted reviews for XvT-TC battle 146 when the competition ends, no need to submit the review separately.
Competition awards:

IS-GR/SR/BR as described below


Competition runtime starts on the first day at 00:00:01 UTC, and ends on the last day at 23:59:59 UTC.

Competition Awards Presented
Award Recipient Reason Date
IS-GR LC Rando To celebrate the release of XvT-TC 146: Securing the Line, CPT Rando's was judged to be the superior of the two reviews submitted for the battle during its first month in the Battle Center. One judge's comment was that Rando's review was the one he 'would appreciate most as a pilot about to fly the mission'. Another judge wrote that of the two reviews, Rando's 'speaks more to my heart'. Fantastic job! 2018-09-07